We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Why You Should Use Mayo on Your Grilled Cheese

A grilled cheese is cut diagonally and pulled apart.
George Dolgikh/Shutterstock.com

If there is such a thing as a universally beloved food, a grilled cheese sandwich is definitely a contender for the title. While you probably already have a favorite way to prepare one, there’s an expected condiment that could make it even tastier.

According to America’s Test Kitchen, you should be using mayonnaise to cook your grilled cheese.

Butter is generally the go-to when frying the bread for grilled cheese, and it’s a perfectly acceptable (and delicious) option. However, it can be tricky to use if you don’t plan ahead. You’ll need it softened in order to spread it over your bread before cooking, and sometimes, you just don’t have time to wait. Enter: mayo.

GreenLife Soft Grip Healthy Ceramic Nonstick Frying Pan

Get perfect grilled cheese in this skillet.

Like butter, mayo is a fat, and that’s what helps to make your bread golden brown and crispy, but the fat comes from oils. The condiment also has sugar, protein from egg yolks, and a bit of acid to give it markedly more flavor than regular old butter.

As for how to use mayo, you’ll make the sandwich the same way you would with butter. Smooth a bit of mayo over one side of each piece of bread. Then, place it mayo side down in your skillet. Sprinkle your grated or sliced cheese on the bread and cover with a lid to melt. Place one piece on top of the other (cheese side down), press down with a spatula or lid, and enjoy.

Want even more secrets to the perfect grilled cheese? Check out our other tips here.

[Via America’s Test Kitchen]

Shea Simmons Shea Simmons
Shea Simmons is an Atlanta-based writer who has written about everything from whether Crisco is a good moisturizer to how to KonMari your space. Her work has appeared in Bustle, My First Apartment, and Make It Grateful. Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?