We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Are There Water Bottles Better Than Stanley—Maybe So

Three different water bottles
Hydroflask/BruMate/Simple Modern

There’s nothing like a great water bottle to encourage you to stay hydrated throughout the day. Few options are as iconic as the Stanley Cup, which rose to social media fame last year. While we love the brand, we had to ask ourselves, “Are there water bottles better than Stanley?” There just might be, depending on your preference and lifestyle.


Several Stanley tumblers outside

Last year, Stanley released the Quencher H2.0 FlowState Tumbler, a 40-ounce tumbler with a sleek design. In addition to the sturdy handle for carrying, these water bottles keep drinks cold for a whopping 11 hours, hot for seven hours, and keep ice frozen solid for up to two days. Fans also love the huge capacity and attached straw, which makes it easy to stay hydrated throughout the day. The 40-ounce tumbler will run you $45, with exclusive designs often carrying a higher price tag.


  • Capacity: With a 40-ounce capacity, this tumbler provides a large volume for hydration, reducing the need for frequent refills.
  • Temperature Retention: The Stanley Tumbler boasts excellent insulation, keeping drinks cold for 11 hours, hot for seven hours, and ice frozen solid for up to two days.
  • Fits Standard Cup Holders: Despite its large capacity, this tumbler is designed to fit into standard cup holders.


  • Weight: The robust construction that contributes to its durability can also make Stanley bottles heavier than some alternatives.
  • High Price: Stanley bottles, while offering quality, are often pricier than other options on the market.
  • Leakage: Older versions of the Stanley Cup have been known to leak when tipped over.

Stanley Quencher H2.0 FlowState Tumbler

A solid, popular pick when it comes to water bottles.


A blue water bottle and a multicolored water bottle

Just a few months after the Stanley Tumbler made the rounds on TikTok, a new water bottle took the stage. The FreeSip Owala Water Bottle first stood out for its namesake feature, which allows users to drink through the built-in straw or the wide-mouth opening, all in the same bottle. Double-wall insulation keeps drinks cold for up to 24 hours while a protective push-to-open lid keeps the spout clean from nasty germs. This bottle costs $28.


  • Versatile Drinking Options: The Owala FreeSip Water Bottle features both a built-in straw and a wide-mouth opening, providing users with versatile drinking options.
  • Affordable Bottles: The Owala FreeSip Water Bottle currently costs $28, making it cheaper than the Stanley Tumbler.
  • Hygienic Push-to-Open Lid: The protective push-to-open lid adds a hygienic element by keeping the spout clean from germs.


  • Limited Washing Options: Only the lid is listed as dishwasher safe, meaning you need to hand wash the other pieces to make the bottle last longer.
  • Few Designs: While Owala frequently offers limited-edition designs, they have relatively few standard color options to choose from.

Owala FreeSip Insulated Water Bottle

We're huge fans of the free-sip design.


A Hydroflask sits between boulders, and a person holds the handle of a hydroflask water bottle.

HydroFlask, a prominent player in the water bottle market, is usually the go-to choice for temperature retention. With a focus on keeping your beverages at the ideal temperature for longer durations, HydroFlask offers a wide range of sizes and styles to cater to a variety of tastes and preferences. A standard HydroFlask water bottle costs about $30, depending on its capacity.


  • Great Insulation: HydroFlask is known for its ability to keep your drinks at your desired temperature for extended periods of time.
  • Wide Mouth Options: HydroFlask offers a variety of mouth sizes, which can be great for filling the bottle with ice or simply for drinking.
  • Extensive Range: This brand provides a wide array of sizes and styles, making sure there’s a bottle for everyone.


  • Price Point: Like Stanley, HydroFlask tends to be on the higher end of the price spectrum.
  • Heavier Build: The insulation that contributes to temperature retention can make HydroFlask bottles heavier.

Hydro Flask Standard Mouth Bottle

All the cool kids own a HydroFlask.


Two people use a black tumbler

BruMate is another brand with a focus on combining style with functionality. This brand takes an innovative approach to temperature control, promising to keep your drinks at the perfect temperature while making a stylish statement. With a range of stylish designs, BruMate caters to people who prioritize both style and function.


  • Temperature Control: BruMate’s BevLock Technology promises to keep drinks colder or hotter for longer.
  • Stylish Designs: With a variety of colors and patterns, from tumblers to can coolers, these products add personal style to hydration.
  • Versatile Sizes: BruMate offers options ranging from slim can coolers to large tumblers.


  • Limited Availability: Because it is a small business, BruMate may not be as widely available as some of the more established brands.
  • Price: These designs often come with a slightly higher price tag than similar bottles on the market.

BrüMate Toddy Insulated Coffee Mug

Sleek and stylish design paired with excellent insulation.

Simple Modern

Simple Modern 40 oz Tumbler
Simple Modern

Simple Modern lives up to its name by offering straightforward, functional water bottles at a budget-friendly price. With a focus on affordability, Simple Modern provides a variety of colors and patterns, ensuring that users can find a bottle that suits their style without breaking the bank. While the brand offers a variety of water bottles to choose from, you can get its 40-ounce tumbler for $30.


  • Affordability: Simple Modern bottles offer excellent value for the price.
  • Color Variety: A wide range of colors and patterns are available between all bottles.
  • Leak-Proof Design: Many users appreciate the leak-proof design, which ensures no spills in bags or backpacks.


  • Durability: While durable, Simple Modern bottles may not withstand rough handling as well as some premium brands.
  • Limited Temperature Retention: The insulation may not be as effective as in higher-end alternatives.

Simple Modern 40 oz Tumbler

A great budget-friendly alternative to Stanley.


Two women hold Yeti tumblers

Yeti is a brand popular among outdoor enthusiasts who demand ruggedness and reliability from their gear. With a focus on durability and a reputation for quality, Yeti bottles are a solid choice for many people. The most popular Yeti product is the Yeti Rambler, which costs $20.


  • Rugged Build: Yeti bottles are designed to endure the toughest outdoor conditions.
  • Excellent Insulation: This brand will keep beverages hot or cold for hours at a time.
  • Brand Trust: Yeti has built a strong reputation for producing high-quality, reliable products.


  • Price: Yeti bottles are an investment, and the cost can be a deterrent for some people.
  • Weight: The sturdy construction that makes Yeti bottles durable also makes them heavier.

Yeti Rambler

Perfect for sipping hot drinks at home or on the go.

Are there water bottles better than Stanley? Maybe. Whether it’s Owala vs Stanley, Simple Modern vs Stanley, or another brand, there’s a water bottle out there made just for you.

Anne Taylor Anne Taylor
Anne Taylor is a writer with a BA in Journalism and a passion for storytelling. Her work has been published on a variety of websites including Mental Floss and Well + Good, and she recently published her first novel, What it Takes to Lose. When she's not writing, Anne loves to travel (19 countries and counting), spend time outside, and play with her dog, Pepper. Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on one thing: making your life outside of work even better. Want to know more?