We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

5 Murder Mystery Subscription Boxes That Will Keep You in Suspense

A person holding a magnifying glass up to a bulletin board covered in photos and string.
Fer Gregory/Shutterstock

Love murder mystery books and TV shows? Wish you could get in on the puzzle-solving action? Well, my friend, do we have some subscription boxes for you!

Watching a good mystery is one thing, playing a game is another, but these subscription boxes combine the two in a novel way. Better yet, the game stays fresh because you get new clues and puzzles each month!

Here are a few of the best murder mystery subscription boxes to keep you busy and entertained while staying in.

Cosy Killer

A woman standing in front of a pin board covered in clues from the Cozy Killer kit.
Cozy Killer

Cosy Killer is perfect for anyone who wishes they could be a detective. First, you pick your game (there are a few stories to choose from). Then, you decide if you want the entire game at once, or if you want monthly packages. The monthly option stretches out the game, and it’s a little more exciting.

Each box comes with puzzles, ciphers, interesting storylines, and vintage memorabilia, all meant to help you solve the case. If you get stuck and need extra hints, there’s also a private Facebook group where you can exchange hints and theories with others. The story is meant to last about a year, which is why the monthly boxes are a little more fun.

Cosy Killer is $40 per month, or $440 for the full story.

Deadbolt Mystery Society

The contents of a Deadbolt Mystery Society box.
Deadbolt Mystery Society

While Cosy Killer is more of a series, Deadbolt Mystery Society delivers a stand-alone mystery to be figured out each month. Each box comes with a case file that has everything you need to solve the mystery. It’s designed for puzzle enthusiasts.

The boxes include interesting and immersive storylines and characters, with all the hints and clues you need. It also has online components for more interaction.

Deadbolt Mystery Society is $21.67 per month.

Murder Mystery in a Box

Silhouettes of a man with a knife behind a woman holding an umbrella.
Murder Mystery in a Box

Murder Mystery in a Box is basically exactly what it sounds like: a murder mystery delivered to your home for you to solve. Each box has clues and items you’ll need to conduct an investigation and find out who the killer is.

While each box is its own story, they’re all set in the same fictional town with recurring characters, locations, and storylines. So, after you do it for a while, you’ll figure out some little secrets.

To make things even more exciting, Murder Mystery in a Box only accepts a limited number of new members each month, so, it’s a little exclusive. You’ll have to sign up early, though—the boxes do sell out!

Murder Mystery in a Box is $35 per month, or $99.99 for a three month prepay.

Hunt a Killer

Contents of a mystery box from Hunt a Killer.
Hunt a Killer

Hunt a Killer is probably the most popular murder mystery subscription box out there, and with good reason. The “seasons” last for about six boxes, so the crime is spread out over six months. Your goal is to find the serial killer committing the crimes.

Every month, you’re sent a box of clues, evidence, police records, and newspaper clippings, along with a detective’s notebook to write down your ideas and theories. It’s based in a fictional town and as you collect the clues over the course of six months, you’ll start to piece things together.

Hunt a Killer is $25 per month.

Murder Mystery Box

Contents of a Murder Mystery Box.
Murder Mystery Box

Murder Mystery Box is quarterly, so every few months, you receive a “curious box” that gives you an adventure to follow to solve a crime. You’ll receive an object (a journal, case file, personal log, diary, or similar) that summarizes the crime that’s been committed. The person who wrote the summary is also related to the crime in some way.

You also get evidence and clues you have to figure out and review. You have to decide which of these are relevant, and which are not. You’re also prompted to provide your own conclusion before the actual resolution is revealed.

Murder Mystery Box is $99.99 annually (four boxes), or you can purchase one box for $27.99.

Jessica Booth Jessica Booth
Jessica Booth is a freelance writer for LifeSavvy. She has been working in the editorial world as a freelance writer for over two years and previously worked as an editor for over eight years.  Jessica writes about travel, beauty, wellness, health, food, home decor, and parenting, and has reviewed and tested out products for all of those verticals over the course of her career. Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?