We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

The Best Cat Stuffed Animals for Every Cat Lover

Serene girl holds a cat stuffed animal toy as her mother holds her.

Cat stuffed animals are perfect for every cat lover. They make a great addition to children’s stuffed animal collections and can serve as fun decorations where pets aren’t allowed or where soft companions are needed. Check out our favorite recommendations for cat stuffed animals.

Choosing a Cat Stuffed Animal

There are many cat stuffed animals to choose from. Keep some of these factors in mind when making your choice:

  • Style: Depending on your preference, cat stuffed animals come in a variety of styles, such as realistic or anime. Cartoon-like stuffed animals are great for kid’s colorful imaginations.
  • Softness: Made from various materials, including plush and foam, these stuffed animals can have varying degrees of softness. Some materials are better suited for display or playing, while others are ideal for cuddling.
  • Features: Cat stuffed animal toys can have unique features. Some double as pillows, and others can make realistic cat movements and sounds.

Best Overall: VIAHART Stefan The Siamese Cat

A stuffed Siamese cat sits against a white background.

The seven cat stuffed animal varieties by VIAHART are made of soft plush fabric, and each one comes with its own unique story. They are sewn securely from high-quality polyester fabrics and filled with white polypropylene plush filling. For a consistent and realistic appearance, their faces are shaped with ultra-light rigid foam. They are phthalate, lead, BPA, and heavy metal-free, making them safe for kids ages 3 and up. In addition, they have been tested in accredited labs for compliance with CPSIA and ASTM F963-11 safety standards. 

Best Overall

Stefan The Siamese Cat - 14 Inch Stuffed Animal Plush - by Tiger Tale Toys

These cat stuffed animals include fun facts about seven cat breeds.

Best Anime Pillow: Auspicious beginning Cat Plush Toy

A pink plush anime cat pillow is displayed against a white background.
Auspicious beginning

Available in two sizes, Auspicious beginning’s premium plush cat toy features feather PP cotton filler. It is longer than typical cat toys, measuring 15.7 or 19.6 inches, which allows it to serve as a pillow that can provide lumbar support. Great for lounging or sleeping, these pillows are soft and ideal for anime lovers.

Best Anime Pillow

Most Unique: GUND Shimmer Caticorn

A pastel rainbow colored Caticorn is displayed against a white background.

Combining kittens and unicorns, GUND has created the unique Caticorn, suitable for children 1 year and up. Featuring pastel rainbow-colored plush, a sparkling iridescent rainbow horn, and a fluffy tail with strands of sparkle, this toy is the perfect combination of whimsy and comfort. It is soft, huggable, surface-washable, and great for those who have a vivid imagination.

Most Unique

Best Set: Prextex Realistic Looking Plush Cats

Six different cat stuffed animals are displayed against a white background in two rows.

This set from Prextex includes a pack of six adorable, high-quality cats posing in resting positions. The cats measure 6 inches from nose to tail and have a very detailed design. The toys are made of the highest quality fabric and have been tested to ensure the safety of kids and even pets, so they are perfect for sharing with the whole family.

Best Set

Pack of 6 Small Stuffed Cats 6-inch Plush Kittens Toys for Baby Girls Boys Kids

This beautifully designed plush kitten collection is ideal for playgroups.

Most Realistic: JOY FOR ALL – Black & White Tuxedo Cat

A black stuffed cat with white paws chest and patch on the face sits in a resting position.

For those who desire a more realistic cat experience, JOY FOR ALL offers its award-winning companion cat. Using built-in sensors, the cat responds to motion and touch with cat-like movements and sounds, including authentic purrs. In addition, the cat can open and close its eyes, lift its paw, open its mouth, and move its head and body. Moreover, the cat has synthetic, soft, and brushable fur for an added realistic touch. This toy is ideal for children, the elderly, or other individuals who can benefit from the company but can’t care for live pets.

Most Realistic

JOY FOR ALL - Black & White Tuxedo Cat - Interactive Companion Pets - Realistic & Lifelike

For an extra realistic experience, this cat even rolls over for belly rubs.

Ellie Miller Ellie Miller
Ellie Miller is a full-time copy editor and occasional writer for LifeSavvy’s reviews articles. With years of experience in substantive and copy editing, proofreading, and publishing, she has edited thousands of online articles, as well as memoirs, scientific essays, book chapters, and workplace training documents. She hopes you’ll find some new favorite products here on LifeSavvy like she has. Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?