The Best Coffee Makers for Your Stovetop

a silver stovetop coffee maker and mug on a gas cooker
Victoria Ashman/Shutterstock.com

There’s no nostalgia quite like the kind you feel when brewing a cup of coffee the way your grandparents once used to. Coffee percolators are one of the more traditional forms of modern coffee making. They are to be placed on a direct heat source and utilize a different brewing process than the standard drip machines we have today. Through this process, you’re guaranteed a full-bodied flavor, or at the very least, one of the wildest cups of coffee you’ll ever taste. If you’re in the market to try your hand with something new, then here are a few stovetop percolators we think you should check out.

What to Look for in Your Next Stovetop Percolator

Consider these factors when making a selection:

  • Construction: When it comes to making the perfect cup of coffee, it’s all about the journey of getting there and how you can burn the least amount of coffee grounds. The material construction of your percolator plays a big role in how quickly you’re getting coffee. Options that are made from stainless steel take their time, while aluminum choices actually conduct heat faster but have a higher chance of burning the grounds, thus altering the flavor of your final product. Depending on the material construction of your chosen percolator, you’re going to have to get comfortable gauging the perfect heat level for your coffee.
  • Capacity: If you’re a coffee fiend, then there’s no doubt you’re looking for an option that can dish out multiple cups of piping java whenever you need ’em. Consider options that hit the sweet spot for you, whether you enjoy coffee in moderation or work from dusk till dawn.
  • Handling: It’s also important that the percolator you chose allows for a safe and easy pour into the cup. Two constant fears coffee lovers have (other than taking a swig from a bad cup of joe) both fixate on being burned: getting scalded by a handle or accidentally spilling the contents during the pour, and they happen all too often for users with substandard percolators. Consider options that feature enough space between the handle and the frame and those that wrap the handle in a heat-resistant material. Additionally, you should also seek out percolators that favor narrow spouts and tight lids to prevent excess coffee from escaping.

Top Choice: Farberware Classic Yosemite Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator

A polished stainless steel percolator with a glass knob on the lid and a rubber coated handle.

A much more round and modern take on the classic coffee percolator, this Yosemite model from Farberware features a polished stainless steel surface and ample, 8-cup capacity for company. The quality of its mirrored design is matched by durable construction, from its comfortable, heat-resistant handle to a firm lid that locks in flavor. Up top, the clear glass knob provides a small window for users to peer down into the device to see their beverage and the desired color they are after.

Top Choice

Farberware 50124 Classic Yosemite Stainless Steel Coffee Percolator - 8 Cup, Silver

A percolator with a convenient window to your drink and gorgeous stainless steel surface.

Most Durable Pot: COLETTI Bozeman Coffee Pot

A 9-cup capacity percolator that features a mirrored, stainless steel body with a wooden insulator on the handle.

A welcoming visual throwback to the percolators of yesteryear, this COLETTI Bozeman Coffee Pot brings the rugged appeal of a classic coffee maker while also featuring generation transcending durability. It isn’t aluminum, and you can bet your bottom dollar that there isn’t a shred of plastic in its construction either. This percolator’s frame is made from 100% stainless steel, while its lid features a heat-tempered glass top, and its handle utilizes heat-resistant rosewood to keep your palms burn-free when the coffee is ready to pour. All of these features amount to an option that can be used inside and outside, making it great for the home setting but more than prepared to brave the wilderness with you.

Most Durable Pot

COLETTI Bozeman Camping Coffee Pot – Coffee Percolator – Percolator Coffee Pot for Campfire or Stove Top Coffee Making – 9 CUP

This percolator is designed to withstand some of the harshest conditions nature will throw its way.

Best Coffee Capacity: GSI Outdoors Enamelware Percolator

An enamel green coffee percolator that is speckled with white paint across the entirety of its tin.

Another ideal choice for fans of the wilderness, this GSI Outdoors Enamelware Percolator is built for the outdoors but is more so the option you’ll want to have on hand for the long day ahead. Its retro look offers the right amount of cozy appeal, coming in a slick green enamel with white specks that looks admirably like your own DIY paint job. And while a homey feel is the perfect complement to a warm cup of joe, the real surprise is how much of the tasty beverage it is capable of brewing. In total, this option can produce 12 cups of coffee inside of its kiln-hardened body. All you have to do is decide how much of that will be shared.

Best Coffee Capacity

GSI Outdoors 12 Cup Enamelware Percolator Coffee Pot for Campsite, Cabin, RV, Kitchen, Groups, Backpacking

This percolator can withstand up to 1,000 degrees Fahrenheit in addition to producing more coffee than most pots on the market.

Best Espresso Maker: bonVIVO Intenca Stovetop Espresso Maker

A slim percolator that features polished copper and chrome on the top and bottom portions of its frame.

Looking for a stovetop option that produces something with a little extra kick? bonVIVO Intenca Espresso Maker prepares the caffeinated beverage in a similar process to standard coffee percolators, albeit in smaller batches. It features an entirely stainless steel body with a keen sense of style ingrained in its shape and bold copper color pattern. Just like a coffee percolator, which it can also double as, this stovetop espresso maker is intended to create a drink with full-bodied flavor, producing 6 cups of espresso. It’s also just plain simple to use: fill, heat, pour, repeat.

Best Budget Espresso: IMUSA USA Aluminum Espresso Stovetop Coffeemaker

A three-cup capacity percolator that features an aluminum body and a rubber handle.

An ideal choice for caffeine lovers who would prefer to save on cabinet space, this espresso and coffee maker from IMUSA makes great use of its smaller frame without breaking the bank in the process. You’re dealing with an all-aluminum body that’s more than capable of heating and keeping liquids warm for a few hours after they’ve been prepared. Its 3-cup capacity may be smaller than most espresso options, but by minimizing its size, you’re getting a quicker, portable, and potent cup of pick-me-up.

Best Budget Espresso

IMUSA USA B120-42V Aluminum Espresso Stovetop Coffeemaker 3-Cup, Silver

A smaller, three-cup capacity percolator that provides potent beverages in mere minutes.

Hollis Mills Hollis Mills
Hollis Mills is a freelance journalist and a content writer for LifeSavvy. He has a bachelor's degree in English literature, and as an undergraduate at Texas A&M University, Hollis wrote and edited for the nationally recognized student newspaper, The Battalion. When he's not writing, you can find him complaining about Boston Celtics basketball or giving plenty of peanut butter biscuits to his always-hungry Catahoula dog, Blue. Read Full Bio »

The above article may contain affiliate links, which help support LifeSavvy.

LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?