We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

The Best Cookie Cutters

fizkes/Shutterstock.com
🕚 Updated July 2022

The perfect gingerbread or sugar cookies require your favorite recipe, the right ingredients, and adorable cookie cutters. Here are some fantastic cookie cutters we recommend for your next batch of cookies.

Scroll Table to Left
  Top Choice Great Multi-Shape Set Best for Biscuits Great for Kids Unique Shapes
 
  HULISEN
Round Biscuit/Cookie Cutter Set
YXCLIFE
Mini Metal Cookie Cutters Set -24Pcs Geometric Shapes Cookie Cutters
Progressive International
Biscuit Set of 7 Cookie Cutters
Sakolla
Animal Cookie Cutters With Plunger Stamps Set
BCHOCKS
Cinco de Mayo/Mexican Fiesta Pinata Cookie
 
Our SummaryMake the perfect cookies with this professional-grade cookie cutter set that comes with five different sizes. Have fun making cookies of any shape with these cookie cutters.Choose between delicate scalloped biscuits or classic circular ones of all sizes.Create an afternoon of exciting baking with this animal cookie cutter and stamp set.Add fun personality to your baked goods with these festive cookie cutters.
ProsStainless steel, five different sizes, sturdy handle, dishwasher safe, strong for easy cuts.Stainless steel, 24-pack, lots of sizes and shapes, good bang for your buck.Food-grade plastic, dual-sided, tall for easy gripping.Food-grade plastic, eight animals cutters, imprint stamps included.Stainless steel, nine different shapes, dishwasher safe, strong for easy cuts.
ConsHandles can be uncomfortable.Hand washing is best, very small cutters.Not as durable as stainless steel.Not as durable as stainless steel, dough must be very chilled for good results.Theme may limit use.
Scroll Table to Right
Who is LifeSavvy?
LifeSavvy is an independent publication focused on a single goal: helping you make the best purchase possible. We don’t just recommend the best Dutch oven for your needs, we show you how to take care of it so it lasts a lifetime and we recommend delicious recipes to help you get the most out of owning it too! Read More »
How Did We Research?

18 Models Evaluated

8 Hours Researched

42 Reviews Analyzed

The Best Cookie Cutters

A grandma, mother, and daughter making sugar cookies and holding cut-out cookie dough in front of their eyes.
fizkes/Shutterstock.com

Buying Guide for Cookie Cutters

A hand uses a star-shaped metal cookie cutter to cut cookie dough.
Skumer/Shutterstock.com

Why should you get cookie cutters?

There are a lot of reasons to add cookie cutters to your baking supplies. You may have little helpers who want to join and who love using cookie cutters. Or, if you’re ready to make your homemade cookies look like a batch from a magazine feature, cookie cutters can help. Special occasions and seasonal celebrations can also give you a few more reasons to buy cookie cutters for your baking drawer. Many families enjoy baking gingerbread men, sugar cookie stars, and other holiday-related cookies around the holidays.

What should you consider when shopping for cookie cutters?

  • Shape: The shape of your cookie cutter can make all the difference in impressing guests or family; make sure your cookie cutter shape matches the occasion or season, or choose one that works for any time of the year.
  • Material: Cookie cutters come in various materials: plastic ones typically offer more complex shapes and are easy to clean, metal ones are generally sharper and produce precise results, and silicone ones are comfortable on the hands while cutting the cookies. Choose one that fits best for you.
  • Easy to Clean: Baking is messy as it is. Easy-to-clean cookie cutters make the entire process much easier.

What is the best way to get a good cut with a cookie cutter?

Cookie cutters work best with refrigerated dough. After all that mixing, cookie dough is actually warm and soft which can lead to less precise cuts. When you have a refrigerated dough, it’s easier to cut it cleanly. Plus, the dough is easier to remove from the cookie cutter. When it bakes, the chilled dough will also keep its shape better instead of spreading out into an obscure blob.

Our Picks for the Best Cookie Cutters

Top Choice

HULISEN Round Biscuit/Cookie Cutter Set

Make the perfect cookies with this professional-grade cookie cutter set that comes with five different sizes.

Pros: This set of professional-grade stainless steel cookie cutters comes in five different sizes to help you make the perfect circles, no matter what size you need. The high-quality stainless steel makes them durable and dishwasher safe. The handles on each cookie cutter make it easy to cut out your perfect circle and remove the cutter without a mess. You can also use these for cutting out biscuits and donuts.

Cons: The handles are uncomfortable to use for longer periods of time.

Bottom Line: This set of professional-grade cookie cutters is fun to use with convenient handles and durable frames. These versatile cookie cutters will also cut out mini pancakes, biscuits, and other delicious treats. These cookie cutters are strong and durable, so they will last a long time and clean up easily.

 

Multi-Shape Set

YXCLIFE Mini Metal Cookie Cutters Set

Have fun making cookies of any shape with these cookie cutters.

Pros: Let your creativity take off with this set of 24 cookie cutters. From squares to stars, this set includes eight different shapes and three sizes of each shape to create a fun variety. Their simplicity is inviting to both seasoned bakers and little bakers. They’re made of stainless steel for easy cutting and maintenance. The stainless steel material makes them rust-resistant.

Cons: It’s recommended that these are washed by hand. They make very small cookies.

Bottom Line: Make cookies extra fun with these geometric cookie cutters. They are small, which will require an adjustment for baking times, but their size makes them extra fun for little baking helpers. While the stainless steel makes them durable and rust-resistant, these are better when they are washed by hand instead of in the dishwasher.

 

Best for Biscuits

Progressive International Biscuit Set of 7 Cookie Cutters

Choose between delicate scalloped biscuits or classic circular ones of all sizes.

Pros: This brightly colored assorted set of cookie cutters comes in different sizes. Each cookie cutter has one side to cut a plain circle, and the other side has a scalloped edge. The dual-edged cutter allows for an easier grip, too. The plastic cookie cutters are easy to clean in the dishwasher, making cleanup an easy task. These biscuit cutters can be used for other fun baking recipes like cookies and pancakes or even for cutting pieces of fruit.

Cons: They’re not as durable as stainless steel.

Bottom Line: The bright colors of this seven-pack are fun to use, especially for kids. The dual-sided cutter allows for cookie cutting variety without taking up more space in your kitchen. Since these cookie cutters are made of plastic, they are not as durable as stainless steel; however, they are easy to clean in the dishwasher, which is convenient after an afternoon of baking.

 

Great for Kids

Sakolla Animal Cookie Cutters With Plunger Stamps Set

Create an afternoon of exciting baking with this animal cookie cutter and stamp set.

Pros: This fun set comes with eight animal cookie cutters and includes accompanying animal cookie stamps for extra excitement. The cookie cutters are made of food-grade plastic for durability and can be cleaned in the dishwasher. If you want to add extra fun to your afternoon, you can use the plunger stamps to add details to the animal cookies. This set makes for a great gift for an aspiring baker.

Cons: The imprint stamp is more likely to stick than the traditional cookie cutter.

Bottom Line: To avoid a sticky stamp, be sure to use chilled dough and add a generous amount of flour to the top of the cookie for a clean imprint. Following these tips can ensure the kid bakers can enjoy their afternoon of making fun and friendly animal-shaped cookies.

 

Unique Shapes

BCHOCKS Cinco de Mayo/Mexican Fiesta Pinata Cookie Cutters

Add fun personality to your baked goods with these festive cookie cutters.

Pros: No matter what time of year it is, a cookie in the shape of a cactus or sombrero will bring a smile to your face. These festive cookie cutters are perfect for a themed dessert. They are made from stainless steel, making them a rust-resistant choice that will last a long time. This set includes nine unique shapes that can be used for cookies, fondant, and more.

Cons: These are geared toward a specific theme, so they might not be used as often as other cookie cutters.

Bottom Line: While no one really needs an excuse to make a cookie in the shape of a margarita, these unique cookie cutters might not be used as often as other generic shapes. However, their high-quality stainless steel material is durable enough to use often. Whether you use them for a themed dessert or just because, these festive cookie cutters will make you smile.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re looking to add extra fun or sophistication to your baking, these cookie cutters can help you achieve your aim. From unique shapes like a cactus to elegant scalloped edges, there are so many types of cookie cutters that can add extra inspiration and personality to your baking.

Alesha Billie Alesha Billie
Alesha Billie is a momma to three kiddos (unless we count the furry ones) who has been writing and researching for over 15 years. After a start as a romance ghostwriter, she's written countless full-length novels in addition to articles, blog posts, advertorials, memoirs, and eBooks. Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?