The Best Cookie Cutters

Buying Guide for Cookie Cutters

Why should you get cookie cutters?

There are many reasons to add cookie cutters to your baking supplies. You may have little helpers who want to join and love using cookie cutters. Or, if you’re ready to make your homemade cookies look like a batch from a magazine feature, cookie cutters can help. Special occasions and seasonal celebrations can give you a few more reasons to buy cookie cutters for your baking drawer. Many families enjoy baking gingerbread men, sugar cookie stars, and other themed cookies around the holidays. Another great use for cookie cutters is to make kids’ lunches and snacks a little more enjoyable to eat. Many TikToks nowadays feature fun-shaped lunch meat and cheese, veggies, and sandwiches in home-packed lunches.

What should you consider when shopping for cookie cutters?

• Shape: The shape of your cookie cutter can make all the difference in impressing guests or family; make sure your cookie cutter shape matches the occasion or season, or choose one that works for any time of the year.
• Material: Cookie cutters come in various materials: plastic ones typically offer more complex shapes and are easy to clean, metal ones are generally sharper and produce precise results, and silicone ones are comfortable on the hands while cutting the cookies. Choose one that works best for you.
• Easy to Clean: Baking is messy as it is. Easy-to-clean cookie cutters make the entire process much easier. Look for dishwasher safe ones or designs that will easily rinse off and dry without issue.

What is the best way to get a clean cut with a cookie cutter?

Cookie cutters work best with refrigerated dough. After all that mixing, cookie dough is warm and soft, which can lead to less precise cuts. When you have chilled dough, it’s easier to cut it cleanly and remove it from the cookie cutter. When it bakes, the chilled dough will keep its shape better instead of spreading into an obscure blob.

Our Picks for the Best Cookie Cutters

Pros: This set of professional-grade stainless steel cookie cutters comes in five different sizes to help you make the perfect circles, no matter what size you need. The high-quality stainless steel makes them durable and dishwasher safe. The handles on each cookie cutter make it easy to cut out your perfect circle and remove the cutter without a mess. You can also use these for cutting out biscuits and donuts.

Cons: The handles are uncomfortable to use for longer periods.

Bottom Line: This set of professional-grade cookie cutters comes with convenient handles and durable frames. These versatile cookie cutters will also cut out mini pancakes, biscuits, and other delicious treats. These cookie cutters are strong and durable, so they will last a long time and clean up easily.

 

Pros: Let your creativity take off with this set of 24 cookie cutters. From squares to stars, this set includes eight different shapes and three sizes of each shape to create a fun variety. Their simplicity is inviting to both seasoned bakers and little bakers. They’re made of stainless steel for easy cutting and maintenance. The stainless steel material makes them rust-resistant.

Cons: It’s recommended that these are washed by hand. They make very small cookies.

Bottom Line: Make cookies extra fun with these geometric cookie cutters. They are small, requiring an adjustment for baking times, but their size makes them extra fun for little baking helpers. While the stainless steel makes them durable and rust-resistant, they last longer when washed by hand instead of in the dishwasher.

 

Pros: Sure, cookie cutters play an essential role when you make specially shaped cookies. But these eight assorted stainless steel cutters will expand your repertoire considerably, thanks to their thin clean edges. The mini-shaped assortment includes favorites like teardrop leaves and flowers as well as a number of geometrical shapes. Now, here’s the surprise. Use them to cut polymer clay, soft fruits and vegetables, fondant, and much more. It’s up to you and your imagination!

Cons: It’s a bit of an amusing problem; it can be difficult to position the cookie cutters so that they fit back in the tin.

Bottom Line: If we could choose, we’d keep this versatile mini cookie cutter set. But it would make a great gift, too. The 24-piece mini cutters fit perfectly in the included storage tin and come with an e-book with tons of cookie recipes.

 

Pros: Beautifully shaped and food-grade safe, these cookie cutters by COTEY have the potential to turn baking into a celebration at any time of the year. Free your mind of tradition with these multi-shaped cookie cutters. Make dinosaurs or Mickey Mouse heads or unicorns whenever you feel like it. Each shape ranges between 3 and 4 inches for just the right size treat. The cookie cutters aren’t just fun. They’re well-made with rolled tops and firm seams, features that add convenience and durability.

Cons: This might not be the right set for those looking to focus on a specific holiday.

Bottom Line: Don’t forget to explore outside the cookie realm. Use the COTEY cutters to make star-shaped breakfast biscuits or unicorn-shaped cheese hors d’oeuvres. Take care of these quality cutters to continue making fun morsels for years.

 

Pros: Behold the all-inclusive cookie cutter assortment set. These anti-rust stainless steel cutters range in shape from the animal and plant kingdoms to various seasonal holidays, St. Patrick’s day included. The Joyoldelf cookie cutter set is one you might store in a single bin for easy access whenever the creative mood strikes.

Cons: A number of users say they were dissatisfied with the quality of the cutters. You may find them flimsy and easy to bend.

Bottom Line: If you’re worried that the bakers in your life will have so much fun they eat too many cookies, relax! Make some bunny-shaped sandwiches. The Joyoldelf cookie cutter set is to be enjoyed year-round.

Final Thoughts

Whether you’re looking to add extra fun or sophistication to your baking, these cookie cutters can help you achieve your aim. From unique shapes to elegant scalloped edges, cookie cutters can add extra inspiration and personality to your baking and munching.