We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

The Best Crib Mattress Cover Sheets for Added Protection

happy baby lying down on a gray crib mattress sheet

Babies are cute but messy—we can likely all agree on that. And the messes don’t stop when they’re sleeping, either. Between spit-up, drool, and diaper leaks, there is bound to be some sort of mess that ends up on your baby’s mattress. Crib mattress cover sheets are a great way to put a little buffer between that mess and the mattress while giving your little one a soft and cozy place to sleep. They are easy to change and slip on a fresh one so that the baby can go right back to sleep. Here are some crib mattress cover sheets we recommend.

Purchasing Crib Mattress Sheets

Consider these factors before deciding on a mattress cover:

  • Fit: The most important thing to ensure is that the cover sheet properly fits the mattress! This is so that it doesn’t slide off the mattress and obstruct your baby’s airways during the night.
  • Waterproof: Some sheets have a waterproof layer for extra protection so that no mess gets through to the mattress.
  • Thickness: Crib sheets come in thick flannels or thinner fabrics; choose which fits you, your baby, and the season/environment the best to keep the baby cool or warm.
  • Hypoallergenic: Not all sheets will be hypoallergenic, but if this is a concern for you, be sure to check for that.

Best Overall: Yoofoss Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Pad

Moisture drops that can't penetrate a crib mattress

This fully elastic and full-encasement sheet will fit standard-sized mattresses for both babies and toddlers. The top and middle layers are soft polyester to keep your baby warm without making them hot and sweaty throughout all four seasons. There is a waterproof bottom layer designed to keep any mess away from the mattress. This sheet is easy to stretch onto the mattress and is washable, so it is always fresh when the baby needs it. It is also designed to be anti-bedbug and anti-dust mite for added security and peace of mind. Plus, it won’t shrink, no matter how many washes you have to put it through!

Best Stain Protection: Sealy Stain Protection Waterproof Fitted Crib Mattress Pad Cover

Packaged Sealy white quilted mattress cover for stain protection

This waterproof mattress pad cover is made from PVC-free material that creates a barrier from any mess or moisture. It is easy to clean and both washer- and dryer-friendly. The top is a soft knit for a comfortable sleeping surface with a quilted filling for added comfort. The pad is SecureStay designed to have a secure fit with a fitted stretch skirt for a snug fit that won’t slip off and no bunching or shifting. In addition to all of that, the pad is enhanced with “repel and release technology” that keeps stains from the mattress.

Best Stain Protection

Sealy Stain Protection Waterproof Fitted Toddler Bed and Baby Crib Mattress Pad Cover Protector, Noiseless, Machine Washable and Dryer Friendly 52" x 28" - White

With a waterproof and stain-releasing design, this washer- and dryer-friendly set offers comfortable protection for a baby's mattress.

Best Cotton: Burt’s Bees Baby Fitted Crib Sheets

Soft Jersey Knit Light Gray Crib Sheet.

These cute and comfortable sheets come in various colors and sizes (bassinet, mini crib, and standard crib). They offer a 360-degree snug elastic fit for no shifting or bunching with premium elastic along the entire bottom. The soft cotton material has been combed and ring-spun for added durability, extra softness, and no pilling. The cotton jersey knit material is purely organic, which is perfect for a baby’s delicate skin, and it’s GOTS certified.

Best Cotton

Burt's Bees Baby - Fitted Crib Sheet, Solid Color, 100% Organic Cotton Crib Sheet for Standard Crib and Toddler Mattresses (Heather Grey) , 28x52 Inch (Pack of 1)

Designed to be soft against a baby's delicate skin, this sheet also has premium elastic along the bottom for no slipping.

Best Flannel: Sweet Jojo Designs Flannel Fitted Crib Sheet

Cute flannel plaid sheet for a crib mattress

This sheet is designed to fit standard mattresses and is made of 100% cotton flannel for extra warmth and snuggly comfort. The bottom is fully elastic for a secure fit. It is even machine washable and dryable, so it can always be fresh and ready for the baby.

Best Multi-Pack: American Baby Company 3 Piece 100% Cotton Fitted Crib Sheets

A stack of three crib mattress cover sheets

These sheets are designed for a standard crib mattress and are made of 100% jersey knit cotton that is ultra-soft and comfortable for the baby. They are available in multiple styles and colors, so there is one for every nursery style! The multi-pack means there is always an extra sheet on hand in case of a mess, and they provide a snug and secure fit on the mattress. The sheets are machine washable and dryable.

Alesha Billie Alesha Billie
Alesha Billie is a momma to three kiddos (unless we count the furry ones) who has been writing and researching for over 15 years. After a start as a romance ghostwriter, she's written countless full-length novels in addition to articles, blog posts, advertorials, memoirs, and eBooks. Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?