We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

The Best Lash Extension Mascara

Anna Demianenko/Shutterstock.com
🕚 Updated November 2021

Big, bold lashes make your eyes the center of attention. But eyelash extensions can be uncomfortable and time-consuming. False eyelashes have a learning curve and sometimes turn into a gluey mess. Thankfully, mascaras have stepped up their game, giving you a false lash look without the hassle.

Scroll Table to Left
  Best Kit Best Cruelty-Free Best Waterproof Best Tubing Best Premium
 
  Simply Naked Beauty
Gel & 3D Lash Dry Fiber Lengthening Mascara
essence Lash
Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
Mia Adora
400X Pure Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
L'Oreal Paris
Double Extend Lengthening Mascara
blinc
Original Tubing Mascara
 
Our SummaryNatural and non-toxic, this lash lengthening kit includes a vitamin-enriched serum as well as a luxurious black mascara.This PETA-certified mascara defines and separates lashes while achieving a bold look.The all-natural microfibers in this mascara work like extensions without the heavy feeling, high price, or time-consuming maintenance.From a recognizable name in cosmetics, this thick tubing mascara adds drama to your look.For dramatic lashes that won't smear, smudge, or give you the raccoon eye look, this product is a wonderful alternative to traditional mascara.
ProsCan make lashes healthier and grow longer, hypoallergenic, smudge-proof, lots of natural ingredients.One-step application, achieves a false lash look in minutes, good value.Comes with an eyelash comb that removes clumps, safe to use with contact lenses, adds both length and volume. Vitamin-rich formula, comes in one convenient double-sided tube, suitable for sensitive skin and eyes, can use while wearing contact lenses.Water-resistant tubes stay in place, naturally enhanced look, not clumpy, safe to use on lash extensions or falsies.
ConsCan be a little tricky to apply, May smudge during application, Not certified organicWaterproof option is difficult to remove, potential allergens, might run or smudge.Application can be messy, prone to clumping, slight odor.Doesn't volumize as well as some other brands, might clump on the brush, can be difficult to remove.Higher price, won't mimic fake lashes, may be tricky to apply.
Scroll Table to Right
Who is LifeSavvy?
LifeSavvy is an independent publication focused on a single goal: helping you make the best purchase possible. We don’t just recommend the best Dutch oven for your needs, we show you how to take care of it so it lasts a lifetime and we recommend delicious recipes to help you get the most out of owning it too! Read More »
How Did We Research?

29 Models Evaluated

7 Hours Researched

40 Reviews Analyzed

The Best Lash Extension Mascara

A red-headed woman uses mascara in the mirror.
Anna Demianenko/Shutterstock.com

Several high-end mascara brands use natural products to nourish lashes while lengthening them. Other brands form tubes along the ends of the lashes to mock falsies or extensions. And others use ingredients like green tea to bond to the lashes, giving them a thick and full look. Whatever your preference, we have some great lash-extending mascara suggestions for your next purchase.

Buying Guide for Lash Extension Mascara

Hands hold a tube of mascara and its applicator wand.
AndreyCherkasov/Shutterstock.com

Why should you buy lash extension mascara?

Lash extension mascara is a fantastic alternative to expensive salon services. You can achieve a striking look similar to false lashes or lash extensions with the right lash extension mascara. Most are simple to apply during your daily makeup routine, making your eyes appear larger and wider.

Long, healthy, luxurious lashes are all the rage. Some mascaras are made to mimic false lashes, so you can flaunt gorgeous, photo-ready, volumized lashes. Other lash extension mascaras can lengthen your lashes for a more natural, everyday, polished look.

What should you look for in lash extension mascara?

  • Allergens: If you have sensitive skin or allergies, be sure to read the ingredients in your mascara very carefully. It’s important to steer clear of any ingredients that may cause you flare-ups or discomfort.
  • Fibers or Tubes: Today’s most effective lash-lengthening mascaras use fibers or tubes to physically extend beyond the lash, so look for these features.
  • Waterproof: Some fiber mascaras are waterproof, while others are not. Some buyers prefer to clean their makeup off easily, using just water and a washcloth. Others prefer to apply a mascara that won’t budge in the event of tears, splashes, or rainfall.

How long will lash extension mascara last?

Lash lengthening fiber mascara will typically last from the moment you apply it until the moment you clean it off, generally within 24 hours. As long as you don’t rub or pick at tubing mascara, it should last all day as well. It’s important not to touch or rub your eyes, though some brands won’t smudge or budge at all.

Our Picks for the Best Lash Extension Mascaras

Best Kit

Simply Naked Beauty Gel & 3D Lash Dry Fiber Lengthening Mascara

Natural and nontoxic, this mascara kit includes a vitamin-enriched growth serum and luxurious black mascara.

Pros: The nourishing serum in this lash kit can make your lashes healthier and grow longer. The 3D fiber mascara is smudge-proof and volumizing. It’s hypoallergenic and nontoxic, so you don’t have to worry about irritating your skin or eyes, and it’ll make your lashes look long and lovely.

Cons: For new users, this multi-step system can be a little tricky to apply. It can also smudge around the lash area and onto the lid during application. Though it has mostly natural ingredients, this product is not 100% certified organic.

Bottom Line: For lash conditioning, this is a great product. The lengthening fibers are long-lasting, so you can apply this mascara and forget that it’s even there until you catch your reflection in the mirror and love the way your lashes look.

 

Best Cruelty-Free

essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara

This PETA-certified mascara defines and separates lashes while achieving a bold look.

Pros: This mascara is a one-step wonder, lengthening lashes without multiple applications. With just a couple of coats, you can achieve a false lash look in minutes. This brand offers a lot of value on the dollar for your purchase, and it gives you well-separated lashes that’ll last.

Cons: The waterproof option is difficult to remove. Some users may have an allergic reaction, so read the ingredients carefully before buying. With the non-waterproof option, some buyers have reported running or smudging.

Bottom Line: For most people, this mascara is totally worth the hype. It lengthens and volumizes lashes easily, and it can be worn daily. Plus, the brush contours to almost any lash line. It’s a great product to try if you don’t have a big budget.

 

Best Waterproof

Mia Adora 400X Pure Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

The all-natural microfibers in this mascara work like extensions without the heavy feeling, high price, or time-consuming maintenance of extensions.

Pros: This multi-step waterproof mascara comes with an eyelash comb that removes any rogue clumps that may form during application. It’s safe to use with contact lenses. Not only does this mascara lengthen, but it also adds tons of volume. It’s made with green tea and other natural ingredients.

Cons: Application can be messy, especially when applying the fibers. It’s also prone to some clumping. And a few users have noted that they did not enjoy the smell of the product.

Bottom Line: This is a multi-step mascara is made with natural green tea and other earth-friendly ingredients to enhance and lengthen your eyelashes. Applying this system takes some practice. But once you get it down, you can enjoy fierce, volumized lashes without any harsh chemicals.

 

Best Tubing

L'Oreal Paris Double Extend Lengthening Mascara

From one of the most recognizable names in cosmetics, this thick tubing mascara adds drama to your look.

Pros: This two-step mascara comes in one convenient double-sided tube. The conditioning primer nourishes lashes with a vitamin-rich formula to make lashes healthier. The mascara adheres to the primer to create tubes around your lashes without causing clumps. It’s suitable for sensitive skin, sensitive eyes, and people who wear contact lenses. Plus, it will look great and last until you’re ready to take it off before bed.

Cons: It doesn’t volumize as well as some other brands. It can clump in the tube, so be careful to remove any excess from the brush before applying the mascara layer. It can also be a little difficult to remove, so be sure to read the cleanup directions thoroughly.

Bottom Line: You get a lot of bang for the buck with this product. It lengthens lashes beautifully while giving them a nice layer of conditioning to make them healthier. Plus, the directions are easy to follow, and the two products come in one tube.

 

Best Premium

blinc Original Tubing Mascara

For dramatic lashes that won't smear, smudge, or give you the raccoon eye look, this product is a wonderful alternative to traditional mascara.

Pros: This revolutionary mascara uses water-resistant tubes that stay in place longer than fibers. You can achieve a naturally enhanced look with this product; it doesn’t look clumpy or fake on your lashes. This product is safe to use with lash extensions or falsies to make them look even more dramatic. It will last all day until it’s washed off with warm water, and it’s safe for sensitive eyes.

Cons: It can cost a bit more than other lengthening mascara. For someone trying to achieve a false lash look on their regular lashes, this might not be the best product since it’s made to look more natural. Some people find the product a bit tricky to apply.

Bottom Line: If you’re in the market for a naturally enhanced lash look, this could be a great product to try. It’s safe for people prone to allergic reactions and those who wear glasses or contact lenses.

Final Thoughts

Mascara technology has come a long way. Now with fiber and tube technology, the dramatic salon look of lash extensions can come home with you. Each of our mascara picks here can offer your lashes a lengthening lift.

Stacy Rounds Stacy Rounds
Stacy is a freelance writer. She has created a variety of web and print copy, from lifestyle and dating advice to small business reviews and short stories. She has a degree in business and marketing and has worked for several years as a social media manager. Through writing creative fiction, satire, and advertisements, she developed a passion for the written word. She enjoys cooking and painting in her free time. Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?