X

The Best Oven Mitts

ESB Professional/Shutterstock.com
🕚 Updated November 2021

Often overlooked and forgotten about until you're ready to take your dinner out of the oven, oven mitts are essential tools for a kitchen, no matter how often you cook.

Scroll Table to Left
  Best Overall Best Silicone Best with Pot Holders Best Bang for Buck Most Color Options
 
  HOMEWE
Professional Silicone Oven Mitts
KITCHEN PERFECTION
Smoker Oven Gloves
Coziselect
Oven Mitts and Pot Holders
Big Red House
Oven Mitts
KitchenAid
Asteroid Cotton Oven Mitts
 
Our SummarySturdy yet flexible and built to withstand most messes you can throw their way, these oven mitts will easily find a place in your kitchen routine. Premium oven mitts that are well regarded for their extreme heat resistance and convenient storage.This set of oven mitts is accompanied by two equally durable pot holders that are reliable and cohesive for your kitchen.This pair of oven mitts feature a nonslip surface, a great price, and an impressive heat resistance. This pair of oven mitts features a classic design and is available in an assortment of exciting colors.
ProsCover over 14 inches of arm space, solid construction makes them steam-, water-, and stain-resistant.500-degree Fahrenheit heat level is among the best available, cotton-silicone construction, built-in hanging loops. Two-in-one bundle available at a low cost, cotton-silicone design prevents slips, withstands up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.On the lower end of what you normally pay, provides excellent grip power, covers 12.5 inches of arm space. Sports a classic throwback design, cotton construction adds nice cushion, available in 20 different colors.
Cons450 degrees Fahrenheit is high but not up to the standards of better choices, users have reported the gloves have a tight fit. Shortened overall size can leave yours forearms susceptible to burns, hefty price tag. Higher degree of cotton makes each product easier to get dirty, not waterproof, heat transfer is high according to users. Balance between materials makes it harder to keep clean, machine wash instructions can be time tasking.Predominant cotton design makes the heat resistance very low, uncomfortable interior according to users.
Scroll Table to Right
Who is LifeSavvy?
LifeSavvy is an independent publication focused on a single goal: helping you make the best purchase possible. We don’t just recommend the best Dutch oven for your needs, we show you how to take care of it so it lasts a lifetime and we recommend delicious recipes to help you get the most out of owning it too! Read More »
How Did We Research?

9 Models Evaluated

21 Hours Researched

23 Reviews Analyzed

The Best Oven Mitts

A mother pulls cookies out of the over with blue oven mitts on. Her daughter watches and smiles.
ESB Professional/Shutterstock.com

From the occasional cookie baker to the next top chef, almost every person should have a set of oven mitts in their kitchen. If you’re tired of kitchen burns and ready to upgrade from your makeshift protection by way of a dishrag, then look no further than this compiled list of oven mitt options that are sturdy and even stylish.

Buying Guide for Oven Mitts

Woman holds fresh-baked homemade shortbread cookies on a cookie sheet with yellow oven mitts on her hands.
Elena Elisseeva/Shutterstock.com

Why should you buy a pair of oven mitts?

If you don’t already, you should start thinking of the oven mitt as your kitchen-based best friend. Unless you’re prepping salads for every meal of the day, you’re likely coming into contact with various heating devices, all of which can deliver a serious injury if you aren’t careful. A decent pair of mitts can be used to pull a hot bowl of soup out of the microwave or act as a buffer between the bottom of a toasty tray and your granite countertop. Oven mitts exist to keep you safe, so why shouldn’t you make the investment?

What should you look for in oven mitts?

  • Heat Resistance: First and foremost, a pair of oven mitts are supposed to protect your hands from intense levels of heat. Many options can accomplish this either through thick layers of cotton or a silicone layer of protection and sometimes a combination of the two. Your best bet for finding the most durable oven mitt is to look into the maximum degree of heat it can withstand before burning or melting; the higher the burn resistance, the better the mitt.
  • Comfort: Comfort is an equally essential function you want out of your mitts; you don’t want a fit that’s too tight or loose when moving hot cookware around. The standard that most oven mitts uphold to bring you said comfort is with an inner lining made of cotton. How thick or thin that cotton lining is can vary, and it’s crucial that you take this into consideration because it can directly impede how you move around in your kitchen.
  • Control: And on the heels of our previous considerations is control because the last thing you want to experience while carrying hot items is a slip. Whenever you pick up a heated instrument, your grip must be secure enough to get it from point A to B. To ensure the highest level of safety possible, most oven mitts utilize nonskid textures throughout the underside of the glove to keep whatever you’re carrying firmly in place.

Silicone mitts are tough, but can they still melt?

There are very few oven mitts on the market that are totally impervious to an open flame, so while a silicone choice is among the most resistant, it still has a breaking point. When a mitt made entirely from silicone surpasses its maximum heat resistance level, it won’t just burn but begin to melt. That’s another danger entirely, as the once-rigid material can begin to fall apart and ruin the surfaces of cooking equipment. Of course, it takes high and focused heat to run into this problem, whereas cotton mitts can burn and spread the danger much easier. Having a fire extinguisher for your kitchen can always keep these concerns at bay should you ever experience a small fire.

Our Picks for the Best Oven Mitts

Best Overall

HOMEWE Professional Silicone Oven Mitts

Sturdy yet flexible and built to withstand most messes you can throw their way, these oven mitts will easily find a place in your kitchen routine.

Pros: These oven mitts protect you up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit with quilted cotton lining for comfort extending across 14.7 inches of your hands and arms. They’re steam-resistant and waterproof with a silicone outing, so the outside won’t absorb liquids even if submerged. They’re also plenty breathable with a soft polyester-cotton lining to provide an extra layer of protection and comfort. Additionally, these mitts are stain-resistant but still easy to clean with a bit of warm water.

Cons: These mitts sit on the lower end of heat resistance for silicone. Their 450-degree temperature rating is just below a handful of premium options, despite costing nearly as much. And while there’s a cotton lining inside each mitt, some users have noted that getting in and out of the gloves while cooking can require more wiggling than expected.

Bottom Line: For messy cooks and moderate heat, these HOMWE Professional Silicone Oven Mitt are ideal, as they’re built to take on frequent use.

 

Best Silicone

KITCHEN PERFECTION Smoker Oven Gloves

Premium oven mitts that are well regarded for their extreme heat resistance and convenient storage.

Pros: With a 500-degree Fahrenheit level of protection, this pair of oven mitts ensures total safety when you’re cooking up dinner. Within each mitt are thick cotton lining and two layers of waterproof silicone that provide a highly durable barrier between your hands and piping hot cookware. These insulating gloves fit both large and small hands and provide extra dexterity in your cooking movements. The built-in hanging loops and included clips also allow for storage after baking or cooking.

Cons: While these mitts promote some of the best heat resistance on the market, they also run surprisingly shorter than others. It’s a matter of inches when it comes to protecting you from severe burns in the kitchen, and at under a foot in length (10.8 inches), these mitts lack complete safeguarding. Additionally, even when on sale, these mitts can ask for a lump sum of cash that you might do a double-take over.

Bottom Line: Here’s another solid silicone option that trades a few inches of protective length for 50 degrees more of impenetrable construction. These KITCHEN PERFECTION Silicone Smoker Oven Gloves are hard-wearing and worth the investment.

 

Best with Pot Holders

Coziselect Oven Mitts and Pot Holders

This set of oven mitts is accompanied by two equally durable pot holders that are reliable and cohesive for your kitchen.

Pros: Seeking a bundle that will save you cash while piling on the luxury? A purchase here gets you oven mitts and a pair of trusty pot holders. The mitts offer a terrific combination of comfort and resilience, as they’re crafted from a balance of super-soft cotton and strips of nonslip ribbed silicone. The pot holders bear the same materials and color shading. Additionally, both products can withstand up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

Cons: One downside to this bundle’s construction is the spaced-out silicone strips on the cotton, leaving the latter susceptible to tearing and taking on stains that are hard to clean. And because both products feature cotton in such large quantities, you definitely aren’t getting waterproof construction. Some users have also noted that they felt underwhelmed with the thickness of mitts.

Bottom Line: This pack of Coziselect Oven Mitts and Pot Holders offers you two forms of great versatility that can withstand some of the highest heat resistance around with the added benefit of not emptying out your wallet.

 

Best Bang for Buck

Big Red House Oven Mitts

This pair of oven mitts features a nonslip surface, a great price, and impressive heat resistance.

Pros: Here’s another conveniently inexpensive choice. Its ratio of silicone to cotton is familiar but welcome, as the ribbed silicone stripping that’s stitched in between the cotton inlay provides excellent grip power. It’s paired with thick cotton to resist heat up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit. Each of the available eight color options covers just over a foot of length (12.5 inches), so you’re granted good protection from severe burns.

Cons: While this option is machine washable, the balance between the two prominent materials makes it harder to keep clean, as there is more exposed cotton in an area prone to getting messy. Moreover, the overall washing process for these mitts can be time-consuming, as it’s advised that you wash these in cold water in a gentle cycle before laying them out to air-dry.

Bottom Line: Plenty spacious and available at an incredibly low price, these Big Red House Oven Mitts offer you an above-average degree of heat resistance and good arm coverage. 

 

Most Color Options

KitchenAid Asteroid Cotton Oven Mitts

This pair of oven mitts features a classic design and is available in an assortment of exciting colors.

Pros: Designed in a traditionally adorable appearance, these oven mitts feature modern staples while embracing the throwback appeal. The majority of its construction, both in and outside, is formed from cotton. However, the underside of each mitt is adorned with silicone grips that provide ample security from slips and protection from heat. These mitts are also available in 20 different color options.

Cons: Because the use of silicone is featured so sparingly on these mitts, you may not be surprised to know that their heat resistance is lower. At their best, these mitts can withstand temperatures up to 302 degrees Fahrenheit, which is over 100 degrees less than many mitts on the market. Some users have noted a lack of comfort when slipping into these mitts, as the cotton interior can feel scratchy and thin.

Bottom Line: These KitchenAid Asteroid Cotton Oven Mitts are an ideal choice if you’re after a pair that’s fairly standard as far as ability goes but above and beyond in the classy design they put front and center.

Final Thoughts

A decent pair of oven mitts is essential to the cooking process, similar to the sheets you use to bake, the spatula you flip with, and the paper towels you need to clean up the after-meal mess. They’re functional in more ways than one and can provide safety without asking you to pay much at all.

Hollis Mills Hollis Mills
Hollis Mills is a freelance journalist and a content writer for LifeSavvy. He has a bachelor's degree in English literature, and as an undergraduate at Texas A&M University, Hollis wrote and edited for the nationally recognized student newspaper, The Battalion. When he's not writing, you can find him complaining about Boston Celtics basketball or giving plenty of peanut butter biscuits to his always-hungry Catahoula dog, Blue. Read Full Bio »

The above article may contain affiliate links, which help support LifeSavvy.


LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?