We select and review products independently. When you purchase through our links we may earn a commission. Learn more.

The Best Pizza Pans for Homes and Commercial Kitchens

Top view of fresh baked pizza in a pizza pan with ingredients surrounding it

If you have a passion for making pizza at home, then you need to invest in the right equipment. Have you considered purchasing a pizza pan? They are incredibly useful if you want to make mouth-watering homemade pizza with the right amount of crunch and flavor. A premium pizza pan is a game-changer when it comes to producing high-quality pizza for various occasions.

What to Look for in Pizza Pans

Pizza pans generally offer a few different design features that optimize your pizza-making experience. They are usually very durable, and many of them have a nonstick coating for effortless cleanup. However, they may vary in a couple of ways that you might want to consider:

  • Perforations: A perforated pan will greatly reduce your cooking times and produce a nice, crispy crust.
  • Crust Thickness: Are you a fan of thin New York-style pizza, deep-dish Chicago-style pizza, or do you favor crust that lies somewhere in between those thicknesses? If you are truly a food connoisseur, you should consider investing in pans that allow for all of those options to offer variety.

Best Perforated Pan: Destinymd Carbon Steel Perforated Tray

A perforated pizza pan made of carbon steel material

This product is the best perforated pizza pan you can buy. Made of carbon steel material, the pan has a superior structure that effectively distributes heat for quick and efficient cooking. It also features a nonstick coating, ensuring fast and easy cleanup when you are done using your pan. You also won’t find a sturdier pan that you can use every single day. This is the pizza pan that many professionals and pizza lovers use.

Best Perforated Pan

Best Value Set: MIKULA12-inch Pan Pizza Tray with Holes 

An entire home pizza making set. It includes a pizza slicer, spatula shovel, and two different pizza pans.

This set includes a metal pizza peel, a nonstick and perforated pan, a pizza slicer, a pastry brush, and a pizza spatula. The pan consists of durable carbon steel material that ensures long-term usage, and the perforated holes allow you to create a nice, crispy crust. This particular set is the perfect choice for pizza lovers because it contains all the necessary items for home pizza making, and they are all dishwasher-friendly. The design of the pan makes it easier to prepare and cook pizza.

Best Dark-Coated Pan: G&S Metal Products Teflon Pizza Baking Pan

A 16-inch nonstick pizza pan with a Teflon coating

This 16-inch nonstick pizza pan has a Teflon coating that makes pizza making a lot easier and simpler. It’s made of a steel material that ensures consistent heating for optimal results. It also has raised edges that keep your pizza nice and secure during the baking process. This particular item also offers ease of use, durability, and affordability.

Best Dark-Coated Pan

G&S Metal Products Company Nonstick ProBake Non-Stick Pizza Baking Pan, 16 inches, Charcoal

This 16-inch pizza pan features a Teflon coating, which provides it with nonstick properties and heat resistance.

Best Nonstick Option: Wilton Premium Nonstick Pizza Pan

This steel pizza pan has a reliable nonstick coating

This 14-inch pizza pan is the best that’s available if you are searching for a reliable nonstick option. This ensures that the pizza never clings to the pan, and it makes cleanups a lot easier. The pan provides an even bake, and it will never warp or lose its shape. It is also dishwasher friendly, and you can use it for homemade or store-bought pizza. You get a lot of value for the money you spend on this particular pizza pan.

Best Nonstick Option

Wilton Perfect Results Premium Non-Stick Bakeware Pizza Pan for Oven, 14-Inch Steel Pan

This 14-inch pan has a reliable nonstick coating for simple and efficient pizza making at home.

Best Deep-Dish Pan: Chicago Metallic Deep-Dish Pizza Pan

A Chicago-style deep-dish pizza pan made of carbon steel material

If it’s a Chicago-style deep-dish pizza that appeals to you, then this particular pizza pan is the best available option. The pan is made of a durable and sturdy carbon steel material with a 14-inch diameter, and it provides optimal heat distribution. The design of the pan offers ease of use for deep-dish pizza lovers who want to bake their recipes to perfection. Many pizza-making professionals rely on this particular pan because of its superior craftsmanship.

Best Deep-Dish Pan

Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza pan, 14-Inch diameter

You won't find a more reliable pan for making homemade deep-dish pizza.

Nick Pappas Nick Pappas
Nick Pappas is a freelance writer for LifeSavvy from South Bend, IN. He earned his bachelor's degree in English and has written content and short stories for ABC57 News and Kansas City Voices. Away from the computer, you can find Nick traveling and filmmaking, though his interests are constantly changing! Read Full Bio »
LifeSavvy is focused on a single goal: helping you make the most informed purchases possible. Want to know more?